Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

In which Seanan brings up an awkward topic.

I hate making posts like this one, so I'm just going to go ahead and get to it. Here we go:

I am not a vending machine. You can't put a quarter in me to get free stuff exactly when you want it. You can't actually put a quarter in me at all. You can give me a quarter--I like quarters--but I am not a coin-operated story dispenser. I am a people.

I give away a lot of free fiction around here, both via my website (InCryptid shorts, Toby Daye shorts) and via this blog (Velveteen stories). In the case of the website shorts, they represent a lot more than just my writing time. I commission (and pay for) the story covers. In order to make the reading experience as easy and pleasant as possible, I have to ask my friend Will to convert the text files to ePub, MOBI, and PDF (which is, by the way, why I tend to shrug when people report typos; they're free, and the conversion is done on a volunteer basis, which means I am not going to ask him to completely reformat a file unless the error is so catastrophically large as to make the story unreadable). Once the stories are prepared, all the uploading and formatting on my website is done by hand, by me.

There is a lot of invisible back-end labor involved with bringing you a free treat. That's part of why I do the tip jars: they don't just justify my making time to write the stories, even if it means I might have to pass on an anthology. They pay for the covers, and for the administrative time I have to take away from writing in order to make sure everything is working correctly.

This is not me gearing up to asking for money, by the way: there was no tip jar in October, in part because one of the stories funded by the last tip jar has not been posted yet. Because even a "prioritized" story has to fit in around all my other publications and commitments, all the release dates I have to promote, all the conventions I have to attend. Because at the end of the day, while I want to tell you these stories as much as you want to hear them, I still have to be able to tell my publishers that they will come first. They pay my bills. They keep my main series going. They have to come before the freebies.

So why am I saying all this?

Because people keep emailing me going "hey when do we get the next free story." And this makes me feel terrible. It makes me feel like a party trick, like a vending machine, like I have no value apart from what I give away for free. I released a novel in November! I had several short stories come out, in several different genres! But when is the next free story. When is the next free story. Why don't we have it yet. Why aren't you doing it.

I understand eagerness. I genuinely do. I understand wanting to know what happens next now. I used to follow Kelley Armstrong's free fiction, back when she posted it regularly on her website; I get frustrated when my favorite fanfic writers don't publish chapters on schedule. But I am so outnumbered, and when all I hear is "why aren't you giving us more," it's really demoralizing. It kills my desire to give things away for free, and it makes it harder to keep working on those stories.

Thank you for reading. Thank you for caring. But please, remember that I am a person, not a vending machine; I am not just here to give things away. And if I'm not posting something new, it's probably because I'm working my ass off at the things that keep the lights on, not because I'm lounging on a beach somewhere. Please have patience.

Thank you.
Tags: busy busy busy, depression, freaking out, from mars, shameless plea, utterly exhausted
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 128 comments
Hello,

I am a great fan of your and there is something I feel must be said.

But first I would like to say how I originally found out about you and your work. It was by going through a search of audible to find my next audio-book fix (audio-books are me version of crack). While searching I came across Velveteen vs. The Junior Super-Patriots and immediately purchased it. While listening to it, I fell in love with Velveteen and her adventures. This led me to then purchase her next book and eventually to branch out into your other universes. After finishing the second Velveteen book I was bummed out because it looked like you were not continuing her stories, until a few months ago I found this blog and found out you were releasing more stories on it.

Please let me say this very clearly I DO NOT come to this blog in order to receive free Velveteen stories. I come to this blog in order to keep in touch with one of my favorite book characters and this is the only source that I know of to do so. I strongly believe that an artist should get paid for her or his work. In fact I sincerely hope you will release another Velveteen audiobook (my favorite format) on audible in which I will haply pre-order and buy it. For that matter I would haply pay for her individual stories if you allowed us to. The meme "shut up and take my money" comes to mind. It is both your right and choice to give these stories out for free. I think it is extremely generous that you do so, but, I think you do a disservice to both you and your fans by implying the only reason they read these stories is because they are free. I think I can safely say the reason they ask is not because they want free stuff but because they truly love the worlds you create and can’t wait for more. The only reason I personally don't send thousands of messages asking when the next story will be available. Is, I know you have other stories and obligations to fulfill (and a life for that matter), and that there are only so many hours in a day. You need time to both write these stories while keeping the up to your standards and time to get away from it so you don't get burned out.

I have never and never will, view you as a vending machine who is only there to release free stuff (or paid stuff). I am truly sorry if people make you feel that way. You are an amazing writer and I can't wait to get lost in your worlds again.

Sincerely,

David Henderson
I never meant to imply that people read only because things are free: the fact that the anthologies sell proves that's not true, and I am deeply grateful. But the amount of email I've received in just the last month demanding to know where the next free story is? Is pretty daunting, and it seriously killed my desire to prep anything new for release.

I know my fans are awesome. But I am still a person, and when people treat me like a vending machine, I am going to balk, just like a person.