Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

How Pamela Dean changed (and also saved) my life.

(I thought a lot about whether this needed a trigger warning, and decided that it was better to err on the side of caution. So...TW: very oblique and carefully worded mention of a suicide attempt.)

I don't think it's any secret that I am a voracious reader. I read constantly. My friend Michelle has commented on more than one occasion that she, as a lifelong reader, is still amazed by the way she'll turn her back for thirty seconds, look back, and find me with my nose in a book. Since I grew up very poor, I also grew up a voracious re-reader; my favorite books were likely to be read five, ten, twenty times before I moved on, and I still go back to them. There aren't many new books added to that shelf these days—I finally have more than I can read—but when I need a friend, those favorites are always there.

When I was fourteen, I read Pamela Dean's Tam Lin for the first through fifth times.

Tam Lin is based on the ballad (which I was already enamored of, and would become obsessed with somewhere between readings three and five), but only very loosely so; it shares a structure, and not the details. It's about a girl named Janet, who loves to read, and goes to college, where she can read as much as she wants. It's about growing up and growing older and how those aren't always the same things, and it's about the things she does while she's at school, about falling in and out of love, and Shakespeare, and "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock," and festive elephants, and pink curtains, and growing apart, and oh, right, the Queen of Faerie and the Tithe to Hell.

The main character, Janet, was everything I wanted to grow up to be. She was strong and smart and living in a world where the magic was subtle enough that I could see myself in her. She loved all the books I loved, and she wrote poetry constantly. It was because of this book that I wrote a sonnet a day every day for my entire high school career. Some of them were terrible, and some of them were just technically clean without being anything more than homework I had set for myself...but all of them taught me about word choice and meaning what you said, and they sparked a lifelong love of structured poetry.

Books were my salvation when I was a teenager (they still are, although I've gotten better about knowing how to save myself), but very few of them had real people doing things I could relate to and understand. Not like Janet. She was flawed and fallible and exactly what I needed, and better still, she gave my friends and I access to concepts like saying something when you needed help, and knowing that phrase would get you what you needed instantly, no questions asked. Because we thought we were being terribly clever, we used the phrase "pink curtains," which had been adopted for that purpose by Janet and her friends.

When I was sixteen, I decided I was done. I was out of cope. I was finished. I took myself and my favorite book (not Tam Lin, IT, by Stephen King) and went to a place and did a thing, and it was supposed to make me not have to exist anymore. And somewhere in the middle of the thing, I changed my mind. I literally started thinking about the characters in the books I loved, and how disappointed in me they would be, and how they wouldn't do this to themselves. They had more important things to do than die, and maybe so did I.

I went to a pay phone. I called a friend. I told her it was pink curtains, and she came and got me, and she did not judge, and she did not yell, and she helped me, because we had a framework for friends who would do that. That, like so much else that was good in our lives, we had learned from a book. From this book.

I still love T.S. Eliot and I still write sonnets and I went to college as a folklore major partially because I wanted to read, and study "Tam Lin," and be Janet Carter for a little while. Tam Lin influenced so much of who I grew up to be...and it helped me know that I could ask for help. So it's part of why I was able to grow up at all.

I love this book so much. I always will.

You should read it.
Tags: book review, depression, folklore is awesome, from mars, gratitude, reading things
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 178 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Wow. (That's an understatement, but it'll do). The feels!

I love Tam Lin as well, although as a usually not-rereader, I think I've only read it once (and loved it).
It's beautiful.
*just. clings. to. you.*
*hugs*
I dearly love Pamela Dean's Tam Lin. It helped get me through high school with the hope that college could be so much more wonderful, even the bits that weren't literally magical. I'm glad that Tam Lin, IT, and all those other books, helped you survive and become an amazing person, incredible writer, and lovely musician.
It's a very important book.

Deleted comment

You are so welcome, and you are so welcome here.

Please keep going. If you need help, just tell us.

dormouse_in_tea

3 years ago

One of my favorites--I just reread it again--and responsible for getting me into Christopher Fry. But then, I love whatever she does.

I especially love the Secret Country trilogy because I and a couple of friends did just that sort of thing when we were young--though, alas, without it actually turning out to be real. I am one of two people I know to have collected the entire set before they were brought back into print; you know it's a good series when it isn't showing up used, because no one's letting go of their old copies!
Seriously!

acelightning

October 5 2013, 00:20:12 UTC 3 years ago Edited:  October 5 2013, 00:21:04 UTC

Although my home life wasn't notably traumatic, the "real world" certainly was - the worlds inside books were so much more enjoyable! I got two or three trips to the library per week, taking out the maximum number of books (8) each time, and returning them on the next trip; I've always been a fast reader. The fictional heroine who served as my world-changing role model was "Peewee", the improbably bright 12-year-old girl in Heinlein's Have Space Suit - Will Travel... I was an improbably bright 12-year-old girl myself at the time. (But I didn't have any "pink curtains" friends, because I didn't have friends until I was in college.)

I've stood with my toes hanging over the edge a few times, but only on the last two was there anybody to rescue me but myself, and Peewee (and a few other Heinlein girls/women). I am very, very glad that you had Janet, and pink-curtain friends, because you managed to grow up to be a pretty amazing woman yourself.

You, too. :)

acelightning

3 years ago

I've been in that place, and it hurts my heart to know that you ever had to feel that way.

Wicked Girls is the most powerful magic I know. You have no idea -- maybe you do -- of just how much it has meant to me during the past two years, during the whole getting on disability thing. The process is dehumanizing in the extreme, and when you don't feel human, it's easy to let go and stop caring whether you live or die. It is a broken, lost road indeed. And there's nothing here at the end of it but a pittance that won't support me, even though I would be even more screwed without it. I feel lost and hopeless much of the time. And that song gives me a sense of there being a place for me nevertheless. It restores some of my sense of being human. It has also been there for me as my relationship changes and becomes something else I don't understand, but still hold very dear. It reminds me that I exist for myself, not for other people, and that I can't let those other people define me. I can't listen to it very often, because it's painful like a limb coming awake is painful. But it's Necessary.

That's the magic you've wrought, the magic of words, and that's the gift you've passed on. You have saved more lives than you can ever know. I have no doubt of that. You've lifted hearts away from that place before people even have to go there. I know some of those people personally. I love some of those people passionately. Thank you.

And I'm incredibly grateful to Pamela Dean for being there for you, in that capacity, as you have gone on to be there for others.
I spend a great deal of time in that place. It's so hard.

I am so glad to have helped in any sense, my darling. I love you.
I actually own this book, acquired on some used bookstore run long ago, and it remained in my ever growing stack of books-to-be-read because I just never found the time.

I think I'll start it today.
Good plan.
...and you pass on the legacy. You're song "Fractal Butterfly" and almost all of the album "Wicked Girls" has pulled me out of some deep depression.

Thank you.
You are so welcome.
I...need to read this book, because wow.

I'm glad you found that book, and that friend, and that last bit of cope.

And I share many of your feels about books. They've gotten me through some rough times - in fact, Midnight Blue-Light Special is one of the books that got me through some of those awful 3am awake times at home while Cornkitten was still in the hospital (so, BIG soft spot for that one). So...thank you for still existing, and for bringing so much magic into my life through your stories.
Thank you for being here.

I think you will like this book.

ironed_orchid

October 5 2013, 02:13:42 UTC 3 years ago Edited:  October 5 2013, 02:14:48 UTC

I love Tam Lin. I didn't read it until my 30s, but I usually re-read about once a year.

I went to a pay phone. I called a friend. I told her it was pink curtains, and she came and got me

I'm so glad you had a friend who understood.
It is a very important book.
Tam Lin is one of my all time favorite novels -- so much so that I wore out my paperback copy. Thank you for reminding me of it!
You are so welcome.

fionnulaharp

3 years ago

Books were my constant (and frequently my only) companions growing up. I was reading early on and I retreated hard into the land the books offered me. I remembered first learning the word voracious and how it applied to me for reading. Books-- at particular hard points in my life where it was going nowhere absolutely and I wanted to escape from it forever; I thought about how "I need to read the next part. If I do this, I'll never find out what happens next. What stories are next." Books are very important to me and kept me sane for my childhood and the years that followed. They still do.

I can't think of a particular book-- but I can think of particular author (who I had the honor of meeting a few weeks ago) and her books ... they give me hope and inspiration and a desire to keep living, keep being strong. I give not a fig that they're "kid's books", because to me, they're hope and wonder and laughter and tears all in a series. I understand how it helps. My /author/ is Tamora Pierce and I found out she's even more fantastic than I ever knew growing up.

I'm glad you're here and that you found that book that helped you, that books in general helped you-- and that you had that phrase and friends that were and will always be there for you.

Tammy is amazing. I am so glad she was there for you.
What a powerful recommendation.

And I'm glad you're still here.

*HUGS*
Thank you.

*hugs*
There are various books that have shaped me, and Tam Lin is one of them. I read it when I was a teen-ager. I had been told all my life that I would go to college, but no one had told me how - my mother didn't finish high school, my adopted father (who had raised me until I was 10) had a year or two of community college, but dropped out. By the time I was wondering how, my adopted father was no longer part of my life. There was no one to tell how to make that dream come true.

So I started to give up on it - because that _how_ was too big. My mother couldn't pay for it. My adopted father wasn't going to pay for it. I didn't know what tests I had to take, and I knew that while I was a good student, I wasn't good enough to get a full ride scholarship. I didn't know what college was _like_ - and I didn't trust television where it's more about the relationships you have than the things you study.

And then came Tam Lin and Janet, and she saves herself, and saves him. It's a book about learning and growing, and it gave me hope, and I figured out how. Not well, as I have student loans that will never paid off, but I did go to college. And going to college saved me - when I hit my dark time, it was the friends that I made at college that pulled me out. I got out of my hometown and out of a life that I was no longer willing to live.

Some books have the power to change us, or rather, to help us change ourselves. Some books give us hope.
Some books change everything.
Books have been my lifesaver too during dark parts of my life too. I will have to read this book, because I can always use an extra life raft for when life throws some extra lemons my way.
Good.
One Salt Sea was that book for me, actually (well, one of the times I was right at the edge). I started reading it while I was waiting for someone to come and drive me to the hospital, and I convinced myself not to pick up the razor in the meantime by telling myself I wanted to see how the book ended.

So, thank you.
You are so welcome.

Thank you for still being here.
This is heartbreaking and beautiful and encouraging all at once. I don't know what is more sweet, the fact a story gave you strength, or the fact that your friend helped you stay strong. :)
I'm fond of both.
I'm glad that book was there to save you.
I think I'm going to buy it.
Good plan.
I love Pamela Dean's Tam Lin! Janet was the first character I ever read who felt like she could be me. And I discovered the in my first year at University, just a few weeks before I met the SCA, which was impossibly fortuitous timing - for a while there, it felt like I really was in the book (though, fortunately, there were no pregnancies. I am still ever so slightly disappointed that there was no fairy court, either. That I knew about.).

Anyway, I read the book, finished the last page, turned back to the start and read it again, twice, before going off and finding Child's Ballads in the library and learning as many as I could. Also, I started writing a sonnet a day 'to keep my hand in', and even attempted lecture notes in sonnet form.

And then I bought my own copy of Tam Lin, and read it so many times over the next year that it literally fell apart and I could quote large chunks of it. For years afterward, I would run across a quote from Shakespeare or Blake or Keats and recognise it because of Tam Lin.

This is nowhere near as profound as your story. But yeah, it's a wonderful book, and while I read it for the fairy tale, the friendships were and are the heart of it, and did, I think, form many of my ideas about how friendship ought to work.

And, while this seems belated in every sense, I'm so very glad you survived.

Love

Catherine
I don't know. I think that this is exactly as profound. It's about a life, and a book that shaped it.

You are amazing.
Thank you so much for sharing. I used and use Stephen King's characters a lot as literary role models to inspire me when I'm in dark places (which, due to depression, is pretty frequently). Have I read "IT" probably 100 times or more-- yep. (the same applies to any of his or anybody else's works)
Yay Stephen King!
First of all, I'm glad you had pink curtain friends. And that you survived.

Secondly, Tam Lin has been highly influential on me, as well, even more so than anything else Pamela Dean ever wrote. The way you buy It over and over at used bookstores? For me, that's Tam Lin, (and Dream Park and the Jane Austen books.) It's also a book that I consisently hand people and say "read this." (Tam Lin is responsible for the beginnings of my Jane Austen obsession, with the quote from Northanger Abbey about reading history a little as a duty. That quote got me, hard.)

I think I currently own two copies, although I only know where one of them is. And it's taking all my self control not to go buy it again, but if it's available for the Kindle, I might lose that battle, today.
It's a good book to have.

Deleted comment

You should read it.

Deleted comment

I'm so glad you had the model for surviving [um... not the suicide attempt, but the things that pushed you into the attempt.] And pink curtain friends.

And I am glad of this without the wonderful books and music you've provided, because they're not the sum of wonder that is a person, or the joy that person brings to the world. In other words, though your fame makes it possible to say these words to you, I would be glad that you survived even if you'd never written or sung and I'd therefore never heard of you. (Tangled my speech, oh yes.)

I love Tam Lin, though I have to say that I didn't understand it until I'd been at college for a bit. It also didn't help that on the first reading, I missed the time setting until I was near the end*, and I missed the hints of magic, only seeing the overt bits.

*Saying the ghost was "class of '97" or whatever was very confusing, since that was going to be MY decade of college, so I was disoriented from the start. It makes a lot more sense when you realize this was set in the 1970s...
<3

Thank you.
I am so glad you had a pink curtain friend. So very glad. *hugs*

I have also ordered another copy, since mine is in storage and now I have to reread it. :P

(also, pst. if you have up to 5 poems, 10 lines or fewer, I'm guest editing inkscrawl, reading period's still open, and I'd love to have some of yours to consider. I know you don't have time to breathe or write right now, but if you have any already done and handy.... :P )
Yay, re-reading!
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →