Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

How Pamela Dean changed (and also saved) my life.

(I thought a lot about whether this needed a trigger warning, and decided that it was better to err on the side of caution. So...TW: very oblique and carefully worded mention of a suicide attempt.)

I don't think it's any secret that I am a voracious reader. I read constantly. My friend Michelle has commented on more than one occasion that she, as a lifelong reader, is still amazed by the way she'll turn her back for thirty seconds, look back, and find me with my nose in a book. Since I grew up very poor, I also grew up a voracious re-reader; my favorite books were likely to be read five, ten, twenty times before I moved on, and I still go back to them. There aren't many new books added to that shelf these days—I finally have more than I can read—but when I need a friend, those favorites are always there.

When I was fourteen, I read Pamela Dean's Tam Lin for the first through fifth times.

Tam Lin is based on the ballad (which I was already enamored of, and would become obsessed with somewhere between readings three and five), but only very loosely so; it shares a structure, and not the details. It's about a girl named Janet, who loves to read, and goes to college, where she can read as much as she wants. It's about growing up and growing older and how those aren't always the same things, and it's about the things she does while she's at school, about falling in and out of love, and Shakespeare, and "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock," and festive elephants, and pink curtains, and growing apart, and oh, right, the Queen of Faerie and the Tithe to Hell.

The main character, Janet, was everything I wanted to grow up to be. She was strong and smart and living in a world where the magic was subtle enough that I could see myself in her. She loved all the books I loved, and she wrote poetry constantly. It was because of this book that I wrote a sonnet a day every day for my entire high school career. Some of them were terrible, and some of them were just technically clean without being anything more than homework I had set for myself...but all of them taught me about word choice and meaning what you said, and they sparked a lifelong love of structured poetry.

Books were my salvation when I was a teenager (they still are, although I've gotten better about knowing how to save myself), but very few of them had real people doing things I could relate to and understand. Not like Janet. She was flawed and fallible and exactly what I needed, and better still, she gave my friends and I access to concepts like saying something when you needed help, and knowing that phrase would get you what you needed instantly, no questions asked. Because we thought we were being terribly clever, we used the phrase "pink curtains," which had been adopted for that purpose by Janet and her friends.

When I was sixteen, I decided I was done. I was out of cope. I was finished. I took myself and my favorite book (not Tam Lin, IT, by Stephen King) and went to a place and did a thing, and it was supposed to make me not have to exist anymore. And somewhere in the middle of the thing, I changed my mind. I literally started thinking about the characters in the books I loved, and how disappointed in me they would be, and how they wouldn't do this to themselves. They had more important things to do than die, and maybe so did I.

I went to a pay phone. I called a friend. I told her it was pink curtains, and she came and got me, and she did not judge, and she did not yell, and she helped me, because we had a framework for friends who would do that. That, like so much else that was good in our lives, we had learned from a book. From this book.

I still love T.S. Eliot and I still write sonnets and I went to college as a folklore major partially because I wanted to read, and study "Tam Lin," and be Janet Carter for a little while. Tam Lin influenced so much of who I grew up to be...and it helped me know that I could ask for help. So it's part of why I was able to grow up at all.

I love this book so much. I always will.

You should read it.
Tags: book review, depression, folklore is awesome, from mars, gratitude, reading things
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 178 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Tam Lin is awesome, and so are you.

(I also grew up with books = survival. A trip to the library was like, I don't know, living on an airless planet and the library was where they kept the oxygen bottles, and you had to bring home enough to make it to through to the next time you could get there.)
I had to stay in the library to get my air. I didn't have a card. I lived on the coverless paperbacks from behind the bookstore, and the water-damaged hardcovers I got for a dime at the flea market.

brightlotusmoon

3 years ago

bunsen_h

3 years ago

brightlotusmoon

3 years ago

I have read it. (Quite possibly at your previous urging, though I don't recall for sure.) You're right, it is an amazing book.
Yes!

Deleted comment

Your friend with the brownies gets a gold star from me.

Tam Lin is how I discovered (and fell in love with) The Lady is Not For Burning, and also (along with The Secret Country trilogy) contributes to my occasionally talking in quotes, although I don't have the breadth of literary vocabulary to do it the way the characters in Tam Lin do. I read it enough to wear through one copy and need to replace it.

Molly is probably tied with Susan Voigt and Polly from Fire and Hemlock as being top of the list of my favourite fictional characters ever.

I also discovered (but only much later - around 2000 or 2001) the secret country trilogy books, which - even if they are somewhat YA and I was in my late 20s when I found them - were immediately recognizable as the books that I would have needed had I found them as a kid, and that still provided meaning, and interest, and comfort. I recognized very strongly in Laura the kind of kid I was, and several of the characters in that book are up on my list of favourite fictional characters ever.







That's wonderful.

thedragonweaver

3 years ago

Thank you. I am going to read this asap. (Because the best thing that ever happened to me, after years of waiting and having no money, was discovering that the whole of the Childe ballads were collected in paperback form when I was in grad school. I bought it because who needs to eat much when there is True Thomas and Tam Lin?)

And I am glad you're here, and always grateful to the magic of stories.
I really hope you'll enjoy it!
I'm glad you're still here, even if I wouldn't have known I was missing out on knowing you. Sounds like I have another thing to thank Pamela for next time I see her.
There's always so much to thank her for.
I love that book and just about everything she's ever written, honestly. I just reread it a few months ago on one of those reread spikes that happen every so often.

And I'm very glad it got you through to today. The world would have been a much sadder place without grumpy coffee addicted fae and horrible zombie plagues and you gave those both to us ;-)
Re-read spikes are important.
its a beautiful book.

Thats a good friend, one who remembered what pink curtains meant and answered the phone.
Yes.
I have not read it, but I think I'm going to have to beg a copy from the university library now. I'll go there this afternoon. Thank you for writing this.

And re your pink curtains moment....you're not the only one who had moments like that. I wish I'd had verbal shorthand like that to express it, and people to express it to, but I did have a local library where I could get as many books as I wanted.....and for me, Tamora Pierce's and Diane Duane's heroines were what kept me going as a teen. If Alanna and Keladry and Dairine could pull through, well, so could I. Now it's heroines like Agatha Heterodyne, and Sarah Zellaby, and Toby Daye, because new situations and new fears demand different heroes, even when you've gotten better at fighting your own battles. So thank you also for writing such awesome characters.


You are welcome in all ways, and I hope you will enjoy the book.
I'm so glad you are here.

That book has been on my shelves for a while now, waiting its turn in my haphazard queue. I think I'll make it be next.
It is a good book.

Trust me.
Like you, I am a reader. (Surprise) And I have read THOUSANDS of books. For fun, for work, for school, for review purposes. And it's nigh-impossible for me to pick favorites. Even just asking me "what's good?" or "what have you read lately?" sends me into a brain-freeze as I try to sort through the over-abundance of data I have in that regard.

But I can always, ALWAYS, claim one book as one of my all-time, never-fail, read-until-it-falls-apart, open-at-any-page-for-comfort, love and love again, favorites. That book is Tam Lin.

Tam Lin was one of the first books to teach me about the beauty of language, the subtlety of magic, the versatility of fairy tales and legends, the joy of magical realism/urban fantasy, the complexities of characters, the idealized mystique of college, and the sheer joy of words. Oh, there were lots of other books which had some or even all of those elements, but Tam Lin exemplified all of those attributes and more, conjuring up a vivid, beautiful, strange, hazy sort of magic existence that I yearned for during my own college years. (And there were a few odd parallels between things mentioned in that book and my own college existence, for Theatre does that sort of thing, it overlaps and creeps into odd corners.)

To this day, I still try to reread Tam Lin every year or so. I agree. This is a book that needs to be read.

(For those curious, two others of the All-Time Top Five are Emma Bull's War for the Oaks, and Simon Green's Blue Moon Rising, for very different yet valid reasons. And some day, I may even decide what the last two members of that list are.)
Yes.

Good.
I grew up too early for this book to be there when I was a teenager, but I, too, recognize the voracious reader and escaper into books. I didn't often get to a library (my father disliked them) but I had a few books, and I reread them a lot (until my father made me burn them all when I was in high school -- a few escaped the fire due to being at my great-grandparents' house, but... yeah). My house now is covered in books, and I love Pamela Dean.

And, yeah, thank god that you had a good friend and a way to ask for help. I've lost a few friends to that black dog, and I'm happy you escaped.
oh my gosh, your father made you burn them? That is horrible!

anderyn

3 years ago

siege

3 years ago

dormouse_in_tea

3 years ago

anderyn

3 years ago

seanan_mcguire

3 years ago

anderyn

3 years ago

I'm glad of this.
Me, too.
The three Early Modern plays in Tam Lin were the subjects of my undergrad senior thesis. I probably own a dual-language (Old French/Middle English) edition of The Romance of the Rose because of Tam Lin. Since I entered grad school for English Lit in 2009 (for one year--got pregnant, had terribad pregnancy, early delivery, and even more traumatic for non-med reasons NICU experience after that, which led to my ultimately-wise departure from the program), I haven't done my annual fall rereading, but I think I'm ready now. Overdue, even, since it's suppsed to be a September read.

I am so glad Janet saved you, too.
I am sorry to hear about your bad stuff, but delighted for the good.

katyakoshka

3 years ago

Oddly enough, that book is sitting on my bedside shelf right now.

I don't love it the way you do, I didn't discover it until I was an adult...gotta love alt.poly for letting me meet Pamela Dean. I am not sure I have a pink curtain friend. But I agree that the library and books in general gave me a way to survive, and still do.
I'm wondering how it would strike me now. I think, having returned for my doctorate as a second career, and spending a lot of time with undergrads with sunnier backgrounds than I had at that age, I may well find more resonance than I did when it first came out an I was an undergrad myself.

seanan_mcguire

3 years ago

Do any of these high school sonnets still exist?

purpleranger

3 years ago

seanan_mcguire

3 years ago

purpleranger

3 years ago

I am so, so glad that you made it through. You are a force for good and wonder and amazement, the numinous and the wonderfully strange. And if I had never had the October Daye books, I'd have felt something was missing, even if I didn't know what it was.

I feel it was Janet more than me who did that, and I am grateful to her.

P.
You are an amazement, and always will be. Thank you, so much, forever.

<3

Deleted comment

HUGS!!!!!
I am definitely going to read it, based on your recommendation!
Yay!
I'm really glad you're here.

I've loved Tam Lin since Kate introduced me to it back a long time ago now.

It's a beautiful book.
I read that book at about the same age, and I also loved it passionately. I didn't get the lesson about asking for help until much later, but it did provide me with a smart, strong female role model that I was sadly lacking in my real life, and it helped me survive some tough times.

I'm glad the book helped you, and now you and your characters are providing positive role models for young women too.
I am glad the book helped you, too.
Many many things in this post both resonated with me. I know this book. I know this Janet. I know that books saved me until I could save myself.

I am so glad and so lucky that they saved you back then too.
I am glad we are both here.
I haven't read that book. My library has a copy and I just put a hold on it. I am big rereader too.
Re-readers represent.
I, too, am glad you made it.

And seriously, I'm glad we all made it, in spite of the various ways we might not have.

I wondered for a moment about my own history of pink curtain friends - I just had dinner in Seattle with two people who would have been short listed for that honor had it come up in a more classical sense - and for a bit I couldn't think of such a dark night of the soul. But then, there were the people who walked me through the process of how to create a new identity that will stand up to some scrutiny* and help find me safe places to disappear to if it came to that. And D & C,** who let me stay with them after my father came and threatened me at my job and I couldn't go home, even though one was a lawyer and they knew exactly the risk they ran by taking me in. And the whole social fabric that meant I could move out on my own at 15 and... I made bread, and played harp, and had a garden, and made dresses and worked at a music store and it was all pretty nice, really. And the friends who did my hair, and leant me jewelry and other talismans the day I took my father to court. (Armor. It just looked like a skirt and blouse.)

(Which, among other things, meant that I was there for my sister to call when she needed to climb out of her bedroom window and midnight and live somewhere else in an awful hurry.)

* This didn't, in the end become necessary, and I suspect the process has changed a lot since the late eighties.
** Whose eldest son I've been fielding coding questions from and helping put together his grad school applications, oh my grey hairs.
I am so glad we're all here.

teal_cuttlefish

3 years ago

I've never heard of Pamela Dean or Tam Lin. A copy's just been ordered from Amazon without even looking at the blurb - I understand running out of cope and I would like to share one of your books that helped you keep going.

Oh and - "He thrusts his fists against the posts and still insists he sees the ghosts." Good choice of favourite book at the time.

PJW
I think the second hand book dealers on Amazon are going to have a rush as I couldn't see it new properly.

/hugs and thank you.

seanan_mcguire

3 years ago

Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →