Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Dear girls of the world today...

Dear girls of the world today;

There is nothing wrong with you.

Everything I see, everything I read, everything I hear, is geared toward telling you that something is wrong with you. You're too fat. You're too thin. Your skin is terrible. You look too young. You look too old. You're too smart, you're too dumb, you talk too much, you don't talk enough, you're broken, you're flawed, you're bad. And all those things are lies. They are exaggerations. They are designed to pick on the things you feel insecure about, and convince you that you will never be happy unless you force yourself into their standards of perfection.

They will tell you that you are weak; that girls can't deal with spiders or do math or love snakes or run nations or be scientists. They will tell you that you must be indecisive, flighty, more interested in the interests that are chosen for you than the ones that you choose for yourself. They will tell you that you have to change yourself to suit them, and then they will keep moving the goalposts, so that you're never done changing, and you're never allowed to be you. And they are wrong. They are so, so wrong, and you are better than the lies they tell you.

If you are a girl, you are a girl. Period, finish, end statement. It doesn't matter what you look like or what you enjoy doing. It doesn't matter what your assigned birth sex is or was. It doesn't matter who or what or why you love. All that matters is that you love, and that you accept that you are you, and you are awesome.

It's okay if you love pink. Some girls genuinely do. I genuinely do. Once, we would all have been viewed as cross-dressing and weird for liking pink, which was a male color. Times change. If you want to own your own pinkness, do, and don't let anyone tell you that makes you less of a feminist.

It's okay if you hate pink. You're not denying your gender or letting down the side, or anything else like that. You're a person, and there are a lot of colors out there to fall in love with. I recommend orange, green, and anything that sears your retinas.

Frills and lace and high heels and makeup are all fine. So are denim and combat boots and tattoos. So is everything between those extremes.

Collect dolls or knives or books or interesting rocks. Watch horror movies or romances or cartoons. Run races; go to spas. Eat cake or lettuce. Buy yourself a toy light saber and make your own wooooom noises while you wave it around; build a cardboard castle and chuck plush mushrooms at your would-be rescuers. Live your life, the way you want to live it, and understand that no one can kick you out of "the girl club" for doing it wrong, because you're not.

You're doing it exactly right, and I love you for that.

Corn maze love,
Me.
Tags: contemplation
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 381 comments
Despite one small piece of problematic language, this is win. Thank you. <3
Which part is problematic? I am happy to fix, unless it's the "cross-dressing and weird," which is meant to reflect how girls in pink were viewed during the period when pink was a male color, and hence wearing it was viewed as a negative form of cross-dressing by many societal monitors. (At the time, there was no socially acceptable form of female cross-dressing that I am aware of.)
Nope, the colors reference is fine. In fact I know and love many cross-dressers. Libby, for example, rocks a tux like some of the most handsome men I know.

The problematic language is "biological gender". The reason it's problematic is that it implies that gender identities other than the one an individual was assigned at birth as being "not biological in origin", or "not normal" as a large portion of society sees it. It is also a phrase used to marginalize gender variant people.

Generally speaking, "assigned birth sex" is generally what I use. It works equally well when describing my own personal history and most of the trans, intersex, and gender variant folk I know.

Does that help?
That absolutely does make sense, and clarifies the language in a way that I had not considered. Thank you very much for being willing to unpack that for me!

I've corrected the post. I wasn't trying to marginalize at all.
I didn't think you were trying to marginalize which is why I said the language was problematic, not you. :)

Thank you for understanding, being awesome, and simply being you.

You are amazing.
I get that. :) And now we are caught in an apology loop, so hugs and you are wonderful.
While there's the hugfest going on: Thank you both for modeling how to have that sort of conversation pleasantly and well. It's encouragement to go and do likewise, and I really appreciate it even though I know that was totally not why you were doing it!
I think that's why we should always try to play nicely with each other. :) Thank you for joining in the positivity!
"I want you to be nice...until it's time to not be nice."
--Dalton, Road House