Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

And then Seanan got angry.

I am, to a degree, a public figure. I know that. I am also a low-level enough public figure that I am accessible, unlike, say, anyone who's actually famous. That means that some of the things I do and say will be judged in ways that will seem unfair to me. I know that, too. I've basically come to grips with the fact that if I want to be an author, and if I want to make my living doing this, I'm going to have to deal with people judging me. That being said...

Don't you ever, ever insult my cats. Don't you ever, ever imply that I own them because they're "status symbols," or because I am in some way taking pleasure in the knowledge that other cats are being put to sleep right now. Lilly, Alice, and Thomas are my companions. They are my friends. They are the closest I intend to come to having children, and while I may be up for judgment, they are off limits. Leave my cats the fuck alone.

Why do I get my cats from reputable breeders, rather than from the local shelter? A whole bunch of reasons.

I do it for the health of the cat. When I visit a reputable breeder, I can not only meet the kitten I'm hoping to take home with me, I can meet their parents and grandparents. In the case of Alice and Thomas, I met their great-grandfather. I want to know that my cats have a good genetic shot at a long, happy life.

I do it for the temperament of the cat. I have had incredibly sweet, loving shelter cats in my life. I have also had bitter, terrified, xenophobic shelter cats who couldn't be integrated into a household, because they were too damn scared. I want a kitten that has been socialized and loved, and that has been bred to have a good personality to go with those good genes. I want a Lilly, an Alice, a Thomas, a Ripley, a Toby, an Alligator.

And yes, I do insist on kittens whenever possible. At best, I'm bringing home a new cat to an adult who isn't sure about the situation; at worst, I'm bringing home a new cat to two adults who already think there's no room at the inn. I am loud. I move quickly. I go away for long periods of time. I do things the way I do things, and a lot of adult cats can't adjust to me, no matter how hard we both try.

There are cats in shelters. There are cats in rescues. There are cats in need of homes. But I am not in the market for an adult rescue, and the kittens don't need me to be the one that saves them; kittens stand a much better chance than adults. Why do I know this? I know because I have volunteered at shelters and rescues and free clinics since I was twelve years old. Just like I know that I want as complete of a genetic profile as possible on my cats, because I buried so damn many of them when I was bringing them home from the pound.

My cats are not a zero-sum game. Bringing Thomas home from Betsy's didn't kill a kitten somewhere in the world that was waiting for my love; if it hadn't been Thomas, it would have been no new cat at all. Do I wish that there were no cats anywhere in the world waiting for their forever homes? Yes, I do. But that doesn't mean we shut down the breeders, abolish the breeds, and become a Domestic Shorthair and Domestic Longhair-only world. It means we breed responsibly. It means we support the shelters. It means we spay and neuter our pets.

And it means that my cats are not fucking status symbols. They are not somehow less worthy of love and comfort and a place to sleep than cats who have been abused or abandoned. They are exactly as worthy of all those things. And they are getting them from me, as will all the cats in my future.

If you can't be nice to my cats, you leave them the fuck alone.
Tags: alice, cats, cranky blonde is cranky, don't be dumb, lilly, thomas
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 263 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Oh. Wow. I can't believe someone dumped something like that on you. O.O

I wonder if that nasty comment was made by one of those people who, a)get rid of their cats when they willingly decide to move into a No Pets apt/house, b)who get rid of their cat as soon as the babies start coming or c)the REALLY nutty kind of crazy cat people (as opposed to the rest of us regular crazy cat people) who make you want to sort of back away slowly while not making any sudden movements or loud noises as you make your escape.
I cannot figure out why a decently friendly cat and a kid couldn't co-habit (barring allergies, of course). Even if the kid was prone to holding kitty tails.

*has a moment of nostalgia for poor old Choplicker, who would let nearly-grown "kittens" try to nurse him because it was attention*

aeriedraconia

6 years ago

archangelbeth

6 years ago

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

Some people can be so stupid. I've owned Maine Coons for the last 30 years. I own them because for me they are the essence of what I think is a cat. They are perfectly what my mind sees when I say or think cat. I have always gotten my kittens from reputable breeders but occasionally get the same sort of flack from idiots. Where you get a cat does not matter, that you are a responsible owner that loves your cats does.
Exactly!
People are stupid and never cease to amaze me as to what they think they are entitled to comment on.

I have had cats all my life, most have been shelter cats, the cats I have now are a mixture of 'Ooops' kitties, that is kitties whose Mummies "oopsed" with the wrong breed, hence a lovely Abyssinian/Burmese cross pair of senior kitties. A Pure bred Maine Coon (because I always wanted one) and a Devon Rex who arrived on our door step as a lost kitty. Attempts to find her owner have failed so here she stays.

Aside from the Devon Rex, my having my two senior cats didn't mean that a shelter cat or kitten missed out, because I wasn't really looking for cats at that time anyway.

And since I wanted a Maine Coon and they do NOT appear in shelters in Australia, since they cost an arm and a leg to buy and are reasonably rare, if I couldn't have a Coonie I wouldn't have gotten any other cat.

And with Ms Trouble the Devon Rex, another Cat was definitely NOT on my list of things to have, so no shelter kitty missed out because of her.
I think people who call animals a zero-sum game are absolutely missing the point.
I agree with the sentiment that insulting your cats is like insulting a parent for having biological instead of adopted children.

Personally, I find your cats both incredibly cute and highly entertaining. :-) Anyone who doesn't think so is, imho, nuts.

How do you keep them away from your growing doll collection?
They're actually pretty good with boundaries, as long at they're clearly explained and don't involve staying out of the sink.
There's a community on LJ that is very large and takes a hobby in mocking people who do not do precisely as they see fit for animal care and adoption. I got trolled by one of their members because my cat escaped and we found out she was pregnant the week she was going in to get fixed. Since we were looking at adopting kittens anyway, we decided to let her go through with the pregnancy. (And are very glad for it, because the two kittens she had are Special.)

There is always some asshole out there ready to criticize your choices. It's pathetic. While I am totally behind shelters and shelter adoption, it's not the right choice for everyone. And someone shouldn't be mocked for making a different choice.

I'm so sorry you had to deal with that BS. :(
...how charming. I'm glad you have your babies.
all i have to say is <3 to you. Seriously, the person who said it does NOT read your blog. I read it and laugh at the antics of your cats. It is obvious that you love them and adore them and they make you happy.

Just look at your comments, you'll realize that most of us out here understand and support you.
I do.

It's awesome.

gehayi

May 13 2011, 00:34:58 UTC 6 years ago Edited:  May 13 2011, 00:35:35 UTC

Seriously? People actually fuss about where YOU adopted YOUR cats from? And insult your cats based on this?

People and their ill manners baffle me. I am very sorry that someone inflicted his/her fatally flawed, crass opinion on you, and even sorrier that he/she dared to insult your family. Because well-loved animals (as yours clearly are) do become family.

P.S. Also, Lilly is lovely.

Thank you!
As someone who has only ever had shelter cats or strays I can say that:
- My first cat, Flower, died of Feline AIDS and one of the scariest days of my life was waiting to get the other two tested (this was back in the 80s, before testing was an everyday occurrence).
-My second cat, Exxon, is wired a bit wrong and aside from being extremely foul tempered, used to be so terrified of EVERYTHING that she passed gas if you looked at her, if you didn't look at her, and heaven forbid you pet her (though she is luckily closing in on 18 and still kicking strong, if somewhat off-kilter).
-My third cat, Boogie, was my once-in-a-lifetime cat. Wonderful in every possible way. Cherished until he died FAR too young of diabetes and bladder cancer. It has been two years and even writing that made me cry.
-Bob, our little stray, is one of the sweetest cats in the world and spends most the day in a spare bedroom (except for 4-5 hours that she comes out to socialize supervised) because she indiscriminately urinates on beds, furniture, other animals, us, etc. It broke out hearts to keep her and not give her the freedom she deserved but what other option would she have had? Most shelters and almost ALL owners would have put her down for the habit (and yes, we've explored medical options, behavioral training, etc... some cats just indiscriminately urinate).
-Wylie- my last shelter kitty in so many ways. I took him home after he spent two years in one of the high-end no-kill shelters in the area only to find out that he was permanently mentally damaged (I've been to the ER for black eyes and split lips) and was inadequately cared for medically. I've gotten him healthy and give him kitty-Prozac daily to keep him mellow.

I love him. I love them all, but I would give almost anything to have sweet, healthy, HAPPY cats. I love reading your stories about your cats because they make me smile. Because they are sweet, and healthy, and happy. I'm sorry someone tried to make you doubt that. I'm glad that you have them and that, most importantly, that your sweet, healthy, and happy cats have you.
Icon love!

Re: Oh my...

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

Deleted comment

I know, right?!
My cat is a shelter cat, and is a lovably neurotic bundle of issues. I love her, but sometimes I complain. This prompted someone to opine that OBVIOUSLY my cat had behavior problems because I KEEP HER INSIDE...even though I don't, and even though there are reasons why you might not want to let a cat out, and it was none of that person's damn business anyway. The fact is, my cat eats too fast and barfs on my carpet because she was a stray and thinks she has to grab any food as fast as possible before it's gone. She has gotten better since I've had her. But no matter what you do, somebody is going to come along and tell you you're Wrong.
The big boofhead in my icon is a gobbler too. He's getting better about it too, but I still find delightful little surprises every so often. Usually with my bare feet.

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

My cats said to say to your cats to say to you that whoever said that to you is stupid. I know it sounds convoluted, but I felt an honest feline opinion was required.

Also, I agree with hvideo, this person needs to become Patient Zero for something horrid.
My cats said to say to your cats that you're awesome.
Wow. You have every right to be ticked. I am totally astounded that some dumb :expletive deleted: actually said that crap to you. I only know you through this blog and through your books, but everything I do know says you're a kind and conscientious person who truly loves her pets. Where this person got off talking to you that way is beyond me.
People are jerks sometimes.
Wow. Judgement while ignorant of the facts to an incredible extent. Pity people don't think.
Agreed.
I hate people being judgemental about animal companions. My 3 monsters are all from the Humane Society but that was from when I was volunteering. It was like well I like this one and oh this one is a sweetie and this one is so cute. All 3 of them run the household. I'm well trained. Luckily the local by-laws keep me from bringing the whole lot of them home. The dogs too. lol. I can understand wanting to know about your cat's history though. All of mine passed away too young. Never had one go beyond 12. It is heartbreaking to have to say good-bye so soon. Going to a reputable breeder is a great alternative. Those people love their animals and take great care of them. It's the pet shop kitties and puppies that come from those awful mills that have to be stopped. Sick industry. So I say fuck you to the snobs judging you. They are your kids and no one has the right to criticize you for your choices. Obviously by the other posts most of us are in agreement with you. So keep on rocking the kitties-whether pure breed or not. :)
Thank you. :)
Someone dared to insult your cats?

Although all our cats are shelter or rescue cats, I see all your points.

In the past three years, we've lost three kittens to the genetic-disease gamble: Thurston, Felix, and our sweet little Max. The level of pain involved in these repeated losses is not trivial. (Nor is the expense.)

Our Russian blue, Ivan (known as The Scarable) has been with us 7 years, but he's still pretty seriously traumatized by having been dumped by his original owner when he was 5. And my own Gabriel (see icon) was a feral kitten from a tribe of wild cats. Although she's hardy, she also has a few personality quirks. She's also totally my baby, so that's OK with me -- but she might be a very difficult cat for someone who traveled a lot and had other cats.
I just wish people would leave my cats out of it. :(
I have volunteer cats, and always have--and I fully support you in this. They're your cats: you live with them. Fuck anybody who thinks they should control that.
Thank you.
I adopted an adult cat, specifically a retired show cat, from Alice and Thomas' breeder. I'd do it again in a heartbeat if I thought my allergies could cope - and if Betsy and Dave *needed* a place for a cat temporarily, I'd get to the allergist to *make* it work.
Who did you get?

jenk

6 years ago

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

I can't fathom why anybody would think that was an okay thing to say to anybody.

Whyyyyyy are people awful. :(
I actually know the person who owned the rabbit in your icon. Her name was BunBun and she was a rescue who lived to be 16 - the oldest rabbit that I know of.

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

You love your cats. That's the part that matters. You take care of them responsibly.

I have one of my own, and he's not the first cat I've had. If you made choices to get yours that took into account their emotional well-being, I have even more respect for you. The reason *I* only have one cat, is because he *is* a shelter kitty, and while loving, he's neurotically wired, especially when I leave for a few days. As in, I *have* to get a pet sitter, even if I'm only gone for three days. I don't have another cat, because I don't know if mine could or would share my affections well.

The fact that someone felt they had to call your choices and your babies into question, that's just reprehensible to me.

So here's more support from a fan, who just got your books back from a friend who now intends to go get her own copies.

Go snuggle your kitties in happiness.
I have done so. :)
I have no words to offer that you haven't already (heard/read) so I will just offer my sincere sorrow and regret that someone said this to you.
Thank you.
I am very sorry that someone was asshat enough to say things like that about your cats. Out of line doesn't begin to cover it.
Thank you.
(sorry, not wading thru the 3 pages of supportive comments)

my cats are fixed. I too wish there weren't so many animals in the shelters looking for furever homes.

but I'm not going to give a RESPONSIBLE pet owner grief about how they acquired their furkids as long as it IS responsibly (sadly, my sister's ex was NOT one of those - he dropped $600 on a "papered" persian then had her fixed *rolls eyes*)

cori is a feral rescue and a major snuggle lover.
Yay, Cori!
Whoever said this was clearly a moron. I'm sorry you had to deal with it, and it's more than obvious to me that you adore your kitties.
Thank you.
I could understand attacking you for buying a puppy mill puppy or a pet store animal or something, but for getting your cats from a reputable breeder just shows how stupid and ignorant people are to domesticated animals. I fully support shelters and rescues, but they ARE NOT for everyone. In fact, I personally won't bring one into my house because I work a guide dog and I have had a guide that had health issues and if at all possible I won't subject my working dog to any possibility of contracting something that would cease her career. (It's been almost a year since I decided to retire my last guide for her health and while I adore my current girl I still grieve the loss of my last partnership.)

I think it's just low to attack your cats anyway; spend your time doing something that's actually worthwhile rather than waste it trying to insult defenseless animals you've never met or ruining someone's day. Ugh. People infuriate me sometimes. I think this is why I have dogs. They never say hurtful things. ;-)
Very true. Dogs are awesome like that.
Who would go there? You're being very kind in responding at all - remember not to feed the trolls, hon. Our Flitwick was a rescue, and our Albus set me back $600 (and yeah, I'm a little embarressed about that sometimes), but for Pete's sake, who really cares - and why is it their business? You're a little more famous than the next gal, sure, but they don't get to ping you on your family - feline or otherwise.

You show 'em to me, I'll sicc my 45-pound cat on 'em.
GO GIANT MONSTER CAT, GO!
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →