Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Like a girl.

When I was a very small Seanan, I wore blue jeans and frilly pink dresses and liked to have my hair cut so short that I looked like I was auditioning to be one of the Midwich Cuckoos. (That impression was helped by the fact that I was a cornsilk blonde who spent all her time in the sun.) I caught lizards and snakes and crawdads and frogs; I collected buckets of garden snails and jars of rolly-polly bugs. I skinned my elbows and knees and stubbed my toes and once gave myself carpet-burn all the way across my face by goofing off on the stairs. I collected My Little Ponies and loved to read just about anything I could get my hands on. I watched He-Man and She-Ra and the Muppets and reruns of Doctor Who, and I never really gave any thought to whether or not I was acting like a girl.

When I was a slightly larger Seanan, I wore blue jeans and flowered jumpers and kept my hair in ponytails so it wouldn't get in my eyes while I was running around the creek or sliding down Cardboard Hill. I drew crazy pictures and read until my eyes ached and spent my Saturday nights watching horror movies and rooting for the monsters. I filled the bathtub with bullfrogs and tried to teach them to follow simple English commands (it didn't work). I still collected My Little Ponies, and my favorite author in the world was Stephen King. When asked what I was going to grow up to be, I usually answered either "a writer" or "a horror movie host, like Elvira," and I was totally planning to marry Vincent Price, because we could honeymoon in any one of his many, many haunted castles. And I still never really gave any thought to whether or not I was acting like a girl.

Somewhere around age eleven, things started changing. Suddenly, about half the things I liked, and had liked my whole life, were "boy things." My love of horror movies was a problem, not because it was going to give me nightmares or warp me into a serial killer, but because it was "worrisome" to other mothers, who thought I might lead their daughters into "bad behavior." This "bad behavior" would apparently involve, I don't know, being able to name the current lineup of the X-Men and explain the mechanics of spaceflight. I was naughty. Again, I was doing exactly what I'd always done, but the world around me was shifting, and I wasn't shifting fast enough to keep up with it. Now, some of this was my fault; I wasn't a very socially aware kid—there was always something more important to do!—and I didn't keep up with the cultural norms. But a lot of it was mystifying to me then, and is mystifying to me now. I'm fortunate to be cisgendered. I have always been a girl, felt like a girl, known I was a girl. I'm just a girl who likes horror movies and musicals, spiders and kittens, Stephen King and My Little Pony. So what the heck is the problem?

Apparently, that is the problem. If I'd been more of a tomboy, people would have had a convenient box into which I could be placed. My sisters, faced with the same issue, grew up to be James Dean and a goth Betty Page. I kept trucking along as Marilyn Munster, frustrating people who wanted me to be easy to categorize. That was okay, because they frustrated me, too. I always just assumed it would eventually go away, and we'd all get to be people, and the girls would do things like girls because girls were doing them, not because of some innate "girliness" of the things, and the boys would do things like boys for the same reason. Better still, maybe we'd all just do things like people.

It didn't go away. If anything, it's gotten worse, since now it's "cute" when I know horror movie trivia, and "totally predictable" when a spider scares the ever-loving crap out of me by dropping on my head while I'm trying to work. It's "strange and interesting" when a girl writes horror, even though the majority of people in your average horror movie audience are female. (Mind you, the gender ratio inverts for written horror, I think largely because there is so much rape in modern horror fiction. Every other chapter, the rape returns. I can skip it when reading, but I have real trouble writing it, current genre standard or not. Maybe I'm weird? But when I write a book, I want to enjoy it, and I don't really enjoy writing about rape.) I'm expected to be nicer, better-dressed, and work harder than the men of my acquaintance, just to stay on the same footing—because otherwise, I'm trying to get by on being a girl.

I am a girl. That's not changing. I am a snake-loving frog-catching horror-watching virus-studying skirt-wearing Midwich Cuckoo Marilyn Munster girl. I'm not getting by on anything. I'm not making comments on gender politics when I combine my Bedazzler with my chainsaw. I'm just being me. It's about the only thing I'm any good at.

Everything I do, I do like a girl. And that's okay.
Tags: contemplation, cranky blonde is cranky, so the marilyn
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 164 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
when you come to Orycon, you can get some nice flannel shirts and put lace on them... that ususally flumoxes folks.
Hee!

bearhand

6 years ago

martianmooncrab

6 years ago

bearhand

6 years ago

Thank you for sharing these thoughts... <3 It's my day off and I'm in my living room clapping after reading this. ;)
Aw, yay. :)
*loves the idea of a Bedazzler chainsaw*

"You're all cut up, and you're shiny!"
Basically!

INDEED!

Hee.
I really love these posts that you make. I like being me and lving in jeans and t-shirts, and then getting dressed up in posh frocks and high heels and getting my hair done. I like that my DVD collection contains an eclectic mix of horror and chick-flicks and sci-fi and Films Where Stuff Goes Boom! and that's okay. I love having a car that goes vroooom! and I also love that my mechanic is awesome and I don't have to worry about trying to fix it myself. I love being able to read maps and give directions and know my way to a place once I've been there once. I love being an artist and a writer and an accountant who was brought up by engineers.

So yes. I love being a person. Sometimes those traits are female, sometimes they're male, and all of it is me. *nods*
Exactly.
Everything I do, I do like a girl. And that's okay. <--Yes, this, exactly.

I've never understood why that isn't enough for people-- just to let others be themselves and enjoy what they enjoy, whatever that might entail. (Well, so long as it doesn't involve hurting other people, but that's *usually* a given.)
I don't get it either. I'm kinda glad I don't.

bearhand

6 years ago

Deleted comment

bearhand

6 years ago

kengr

6 years ago

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

I'm fortunate to be cisgendered. I have always been a girl, felt like a girl, known I was a girl. I'm just a girl who likes horror movies and musicals, spiders and kittens, Stephen King and My Little Pony.

...and I was a girl for whom math was my easiest A and writing was a B or C (and actually more interesting because I had to work at it) and I majored in computer science and read Loveswept romances and Robert B Parker and Madeleine L'Engle.

I don't know what brought your rant on today. I too have had the rejection of other girls for doing boy things (and puzzlement of boys for not being a true tomboy despite tutoring them in programming and math) and I too feel fortunate for knowing I was cisgendered. Because I certainly had enough people telling me I wasn't that it would've been very uncomfortable to have had doubts. If it helps, I totally get it.
My rant comes from many directions. I've just sort of hit "fed up" with certain things.
Thank you for posting this! It sucks to hit the "%$#!" point that triggers being fed up, but I'm sure I am not the only girl who is happy to hear these thoughts from someone besides ourselves. I'm a horror-movie-loving jewelry-collecting software-studying tech loving girl. It's a little lonely in The Pit (I work at a newspaper right now.)
You're welcome to come over to my Pit any time.
Thank you. Just... thank you.
You're very welcome.
??!!?? If rape is that pervasive in modern horror, it makes me glad that I don't read modern horror. (As I've said before, I consider Feed SF.)

And if I ever try to force you into a box or otherwise treat you that stupidly, you are encouraged to hit me. (And I really don't like being hit.)
Feed is definitely SF.

Deleted comment

I don't take that as snarky at all.

I am glad to exist for you. :)
Oh yes, this. I do know what you mean, from the inside, about not fitting people's neat little gender-boxes. It's fostered this powerful desire to mess with people's preconceptions :)
You're a party game!

And a ROCKET SCIENTIST!
AMEN!!!!
As a child, because I was bold and brave and spoke my young mind at people instead of hiding behind my mothers skirts and being "Properly shy"- I was "Hyperactive" and "Needed to be put on Ritalin"...
My Mother told them to go to Hell and get AWAY from her child!
:)
Your mother rocks.

lysystratae

6 years ago

work harder than the men of my acquaintance, just to stay on the same footing—because otherwise, I'm trying to get by on being a girl.


It's insidious, that implicit assumption that you're trading on your gender. It's a no-win thing, too, because "getting by by being a girl" is in the eye of the beholder, not the mind or intentions of the woman in question. And anyway, how do you prove a negative?

Also, why doesn't anyone ever ask if the men are "getting by on being a guy?"
I know, right?

When I act normally, I'm "playing to my girliness," but when I act normally and they don't like it, I'm "being a bitch." There's no winning.
Yeah, stupid people & their stupid boxes. The only way to win some games is not to play. Fortunately, I figured that out long before War Games premiered.

The only box *I* belong in says "Police Public Call Box" above the door & travels in time.



I just want to say that I LOVE YOUR ICON. (sorry, couldn't help it)

starmalachite

6 years ago

brownkitty

6 years ago

Hear hear.
Ja.

kyra_neko_rei

August 13 2010, 20:38:53 UTC 6 years ago Edited:  August 13 2010, 20:39:10 UTC

This.

I love the juxtapositions and hybrids of different boxes. They are rich, in some way that boxes are not . . . or maybe it's just that boxes are the default that so many people fit into, and so someone who is unboxed or mix-boxed is a sign of someone who is true to themselves.

Whenever I dress up, dress and makeup and whatnot, there's a part of me that hopes to get a flat tire, for the image people will see as they drive by: me in a flowy white romantic-looking dress and long flowing hair, barefoot 'cause I hate the shoes, changing the tire on the side of the road, and smiling 'cause I'm doing something I enjoy. Hopefully it will be raining, and there will be mud.
I love that image...

...and I worry about your dress!

kyra_neko_rei

6 years ago

Fellow chick horror writer question, re the rape standard: Do you really feel like you're being not just encouraged but expected to write it? Because I never have, and I'm interested by this idea. (Maybe I've simply avoided getting this particular message by putting stuff straight dudes usually find far more icky in my writing, but...hmmm.)

Also: Got Rosemary & Rue out of the library today. Very much looking forward to it.;)
I think it's expected, but you can do without it, and really, you should. A lot of people need their rape buttons taken away. Rape is not the bacon of horror literature.

tintiger

6 years ago

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

I miss She-Ra...and personally, I'm glad you don't write rape, it's nice to have something different out there. I have a question (and yes I know you post entries where if people have questions see this entry but I can't find it at the moment and I am very excited to get your answer (no it is not about any of your plots or meeting in person)) would it be all right if I private messaged you?
Sure, go for it! You'll get a faster response through my website contact form.

pyre006

6 years ago

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

pyre006

6 years ago

seanan_mcguire

6 years ago

Thank you! For all of it! This is what I'm trying to teach my daughter, who at 3 loves sparkles, ponies, puppies, and crocodiles. She likes dirt and sticks and pretty, pretty dresses. So I make her fluffy dresses, with full skirts and puffy sleeves and sturdy lace and sparkles. She's free to do whatever she wants as long as she's in in danger of major bodily harm. When she gets a little older, we'll let her at the car engines she very badly wants to take apart now and I'll teach her how to make the pretty pretty dresses.

Everyone should be who they want to be and how they want to be. Boxes are for stuff, not people.
Okay, dude, 1) Your daughter rules, and 2) If you want to send me your mailing address through my website contact form, I have a few boxed My Little Ponies (G3 duplicates) that might very much appreciate a three-year-old who wants to feed them to a crocodile.
As you can tell, I'm a guy, and I'm frustrated with the cheap 'rape' writing in much of horror today. I personally wish they'd try to be, I don't know, creative maybe, and try for something scary.

In Stephen King's It, did the clown try to rape you? No, but he was still a scary sumbitch.

I just saying.
...

NO BUT THANKS FOR THAT IMAGE.

Aigh.

I'm much the same.

snowcoma

August 13 2010, 21:23:25 UTC 6 years ago Edited:  August 13 2010, 21:44:16 UTC

I am a Hallowe'en loving, pointy-nailed, purple-haired, bone-collecting, horror-addicted goth girl who loves children, rescues animals, and truly means it each time I say "have a good day!"

But just because I am a good person, and just because they couldn't be more wrong about me if they tried, it does not mean it doesn't hurt like hell. I never wanted to be different or special, I just wanted to be myself. Some days I'm caught completely off-guard by the harsh comments, because I forget that I'm not like everyone else. I don't look at others and think "different than me"; why can't I be afforded the same courtesy?


Thank you for being Seanan. I love you for exactly who you are, and I think we're all lucky to have you in our world.


EDIT: Thanks to medication-fog, I completely forgot to include the gender aspect in my comment. I had a mohawk for over four years, and kept the sides/back of my head clean shaven. One of my most beloved articles of clothing is an old leather jacket with a chain hanging from the epaulets (his name is Binky). I wear whatever the hell I want, provided it fits me, which leads to a pretty even ratio of "male" and "female" clothing. It flummoxed the hell out of people when I walked in with a shaved head, motorcycle jacket, combat boots, pretty makeup, and a swishy skirt.

I did have one gender-guessing situation that ended well enough to be mentioned here: I was walking to the grocery store a few years ago, and heard some 8-10 year-olds playing nearby. One said "Is it a boy, or a girl?", to which I spun on my heel and said "IT is a girl, and can hear you."

The part that makes it awesome was the response I got. "I'm sorry! That was really, incredibly insensitive. I'm sorry." Not only does the kid get points for good vocabulary and proper apology, the entire group listened to me while I forgave him, and gave a mini-lecture on gender and why it is bad to ever refer to a human as "it".

I went on my way, and felt a little better for knowing that I might have just averted some transphobia in our future generation. Fingers crossed.
I love you, too, for being just who you are.

And good on you, for educating.
As an elementary school girl, I was not "allowed" on the "girls" side of the playground by the other girls. I didn't match their expectations, reading comics, SF and watching "boy" cartoons, much like you.

But I wasn't a physical tomboy, either, and got teased for "throwing like a girl" by the boys.

My daughter, autistic and age seven, loves her girlie dresses and her Star Wars lightsaber battles fairly equally. I hope this keeps up.
This is because your daughter is awesome.
And you go, girl.

Hell with their expectations anyway.
Exactly.
*clicks the 'like' button*

I always wondered, as a kid, why I wasn't supposed to like both Power Rangers *and* playing dress-up.
No idea.
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →