Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

In defense of the blonde: one Marilyn's plea.

Mary Robinette Kowal—who is fantastic and awesome and incidentally, the person reading the Toby Daye audio books, which means hers is a voice I'm going to be hearing quite a lot of—made a blog post previewing the upcoming fantasy movies of 2010. It's a good post, which is no surprise, since she's a good author and a great lady. But one line, talking about Disney's upcoming Rapunzel, sort of hit me the wrong way:

"Hey! Disney's doing another classic fairy tale. While I could wish that the princess here weren't your cliche blond, I also have to acknowledge that this is true to the Brothers Grimm story."

I'm blonde. This is a choice now, since I'm old enough to dye my hair, but when I was first forming my self-image, it was just a biological reality. I've spent my entire life being bombarded with Barbie and bimbo stereotypes, from Kelly Bundy on Married...With Children to an endless procession of evil stepmothers and nasty girlfriends on the silver screen. That wasn't always the case; "America's sweethearts" used to be almost exclusively blonde girls, who might not be smart or independent, but they were plucky and beautiful and they got the guy, so hey, let's rock with that, okay? But the age of the blonde as leading lady ended before I was born, and except for Barbie—who seems to be basically unkillable—it hasn't really shown much sign of coming back. Gwen Stacy was replaced by Mary Jane. Supergirl's comic got canceled on a regular basis. Maybe it's because all the science fiction I watched was supposed to be about the male hero, so they didn't want to make the women too "flashy," but all the smart, interesting, active women on television seemed to be brunette...unless they were all about their sexy hot bodies of sexy hotness, in which case, they could be blonde, but don't forget, unless you're hot and blonde, you don't count.

Growing up, I was able to find exactly three smart, blonde, accessible fictional characters to idolize as role models: Marilyn Munster from The Munsters, Sue Richards of the Fantastic Four, and Terra of the Teen Titans. Terra eventually turned out to be totally evil (and hence got dropped from the list), only to be replaced by Illyana Rasputin, who...promptly died. Whoops. Marilyn and Sue endured, and even if Sue was occasionally a soccer mom, they remained blonde and awesome. (Marilyn was also the first firm indication I got that it was okay to like monsters and frilly pink dresses. I owe a lot to Marilyn Munster.) Like every kid, I wanted some reassurance that I was okay the way I was, and a lot of what I got from the media was that I would only be okay if I either suffered severe head trauma or dyed my hair.

This? Sucked.

The ongoing transition of the blonde from girl-next-door and America's sweetheart has continued, and now she's not just the bimbo, she's the bad guy. I started making lists of movies and television shows with blonde characters, and nine times out of ten, if you have a blonde at all, she's evil. If she's not evil, the bad guy? Is also blonde. Movies that break this trend: Legally Blonde (where all the blondes are presented as well-meaning ditzes who are smart despite the satin-finish manicures, or dumb but sweet), and Jennifer's Body (where Needy is Hollywood ugly-pretty, and plays the foil to an evil brunette sexpot). There are more blondes on television (thank you, Veronica Mars, thank you), but they're still very rare in-genre, and there, they're usually cannon fodder.

And then there are the princesses. See, the reason this comment bothered me in the first place is that I've heard it before, many times. "Oh, at least Disney's new princess isn't blonde." "Oh, it looks insipid, but at least the princess isn't blonde." Well, excluding animals (so Nala doesn't count), there have been four blonde Disney protagonists: Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Alice, and Eilonwy. Oh, and Tinker Bell, who sort of exists in her own little bubble. The most recent of these characters, Eilonwy, was created in 1985, when The Black Cauldron flopped at a theater near you. Prior to that, we had Sleeping Beauty in 1959. Princesses/protagonists in the last twenty years have been brunette (Belle, Jane), black haired (Jasmine, Pocahontas, Esmerelda, Mulan, Lilo, Nani, Tiana), redheads (Megara), or white haired (Kida). (Ariel just misses this cut, as The Little Mermaid came out in 1989. Redheads are really under-represented, by the way, unless you count Giselle from Enchanted and Penny from Bolt, and then they just wind up in the boat with the blondes.)

Blonde girls deserve a smart, savvy, modern Disney princess with agency. We didn't use up all our princesses when we got Cinderella and Aurora, and the fact that they left Alice blonde doesn't make up for turning Dorothy brunette. So instead of wishing this princess weren't blonde, how about we say "yay, about time," and keep making it okay for blonde girls to be smart, just like everybody else?
Tags: media addict, shameless plea, so the marilyn
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 116 comments
Apropos of not much of anything, Eilonwy in the books has 'red-gold hair'.

That said, I'm going to agree with Vixy's above-statement. It's not the "oh-god, another blonde", it's, "oh-god, they're hitting us with another stereotype."

Also. Two words for not-stupid, ballsy blonde. Rose Tyler.
True! Strawberry blonde is one of those awesome colors where people assume you're dumb (blonde) and easy (redhead). No winning!

British TV is generally better about giving us blondes who're allowed to be smarter than toast. Abby Maitland on Primeval and Susan on Coupling are excellent examples.
Funny, I never picked up on 'redhead means easy'. Every stereotype I've ever seen with redheads is "don't piss them off, they have nasty tempers." This coming from a woman whose mom was a redhead and a Leo and had a nasty temper. :)
Having been hit on constantly during my entire adolescence because of the "redheads love sex - hopefully with you" stereotype, I'd have to say it's definitely out there.

--Ember--
I'm glad I missed it, then. I've always seen that redheads were seen as the most desireable, but not the most easily 'gotten'. In my little area of the South? That would be blonde. And brunettes were envious of everyone else.
Well, I also got a lot of the "A slut will sleep with anyone, a bitch will sleep with anyone but you stereotype." Why they assumed I was saying yes to somebody at all, though, I'm not sure.

In fact I was turning them all down. So I'm guessing it was the stereotype that prompted them to assume somebody was getting some out of me. But the stereotype was frequently cited in their pickup lines.

--Ember--
Heh. I was generally a bitch.
That's really interested to me because I've been coloring my hair red since I was 17. Naturally it's mouse brown, fine and the grey started up at 16. Everyone who knows me since then is often startled when I tell them it's not "natural" because I'm the 'stereotypical' ballsy redhead with a temper and an attitude.
Hmm, I'm a natural redhead. Folks expected me to be passionate in all ways. They expected me to want lots of sex, to be really intense, to lose my temper easily, and to be pushy and gutsy. They also expected me to be smart, but I don't think that was from the hair.

I have to admit, I DO have a hereditary temper from my Dad's side, so that's fair, I guess. I'm wondering if the pushy and gutsy is a result of being pushed around as a kid, such that you learn to push back, or if that, too, is somehow hereditary, but it does apply. The expectations on my sexuality were the big part of the Redhead stereotype that didn't apply as folks seemed to hope, and so it stands out to me as the one that was the most troublesome for me to deal with as a teenager. The rest of it I couldn't deny, so it didn't bother me as much.

--Ember--
My analagous response to yours is that I was 16 when a certain fast food restaurant premiered their "Wendy's Hot and Juicy" add campaign. This made my senior year of high schoool in many ways a living hell.

I came up with a better way to phrase it in another reply - "I never defined myself by how I looked, I decided to look how I defined myself". Being in theatre, you get a kind of skewed perception about looks. I perceived redheads as outgoing fiesty girls who don't take shit from anyone, and also I like the aspect of being "different" as it's not a common shade. If I thought about any sexual aspect at all it might have been that a redhead was more likely to "take charge" there too - and might well have the guts to proposition a guy if she were so inclined!

I remember reading that in the US, when a woman decides to change her hair color (as opposed to covering grey) the most common color is blonde followed by shades of red. I find this interesting when I read about things in Britain like "Kick a Ginger Day".
Yeah, my experience with Theatre is that redheads are fairly well appreciated there. I've heard directors comment that red hair is just so much more dynamic looking under the lights, and other such appreciation. But that may be the particular directors I've happened to encounter.

I don't think Theatre is the skew, I think all the stereotypes you and I are describing fit together into a larger stereotype, and it's just the reactions that vary.

--Ember--
My experience, being British (and also male and over 50) was that redheaded males, especially boys but also a number of men, got picked on ('Ginger' was one of the least of the epithets -- 'carrottop', 'coppernob', etc. were possibly more common). Redheaded girls seemed to be desirable but no one with any sense would even try anything on because they would (stereotype) rip you to shreds. Auburn, on the other hand, was seen as rather "upper class", desirable but probably not interested in the plebs.

We got some of the "dumb blonde" stuff over here, mostly via American TV shows I suspect, but we also had a number of strong blonde characters on TV (Lady Penelope from Thunderbirds was a heroine to a lot of blonde girls when I was growing up). But more we had the "blonde and pretty girl" equals "don't have to do anything", men would fall over and do anything such a girl asked so she didn't have to try (and in fact there was motivation for her to use her looks rather than do anything herself[1]). Too many fell for that, a few deliberately rebelled against it.

Yes, there are a lot of "dyed red" women over here. Natural redheads are a lot more rare. The same with blondes.

[1] In a similar vein, teachers discovered that a lot of children who "couldn't read" had realised that if you admitted to being able to read you had to do more work, whereas if you "couldn't read" you got put in 'remedial' classes where the work was easier and you could sit there daydreaming while pretending that you were struggling with the text.
The anti-redhead thing has been around for a long time. I believe (but haven't looked it up) that it goes back as far as the middle ages, when the church started teaching that Judas had red hair.
"smarter than toast" got a good laugh. Consider the phrase stolen. :)

And yay! for Susan! I loved how she was pretty much the only source of sanity for the girls - but even then was occasionally allowed to have her own little foibles and personal quirks.

"G'day, Bruce's Bar and Grill."