Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

...gee, that's exactly what we needed.

A brief primer for those who don't live in the San Francisco Bay Area:

The Bay Area is actually very large. Yes, there is life outside San Francisco, San Jose, and Oakland. I realize you may never have heard of any cities or towns outside these major population centers, but I promise you, it exists. Thousands of people live in places with names like "Albany," "Pleasant Hill," "Los Gatos," and "Hercules." I, myself, live in a city called "Concord," which used to be called, at various points in its history, "Canterbury," "Todo Santos," and "The Ass-End of Nowhere." The Bay Area contains mountains, small forests, inconveniently-placed hills, and lots of other quirky geography. Because of this, our roads and bridges are occasionally very odd, and do things that make little to no actual sense.

There are a multitude of ways to get around the Bay Area. If you're in the South Bay, you have CalTrain, a swift series of, well, trains that can get you to San Francisco. If you're in San Francisco, the odds are good that you never actually leave San Francisco, so your transit options are "car," "bus," "taxi," "foot," and "magic carpet." If you're in the East Bay, there's a good chance that you work in San Francisco or the Oakland/Berkeley area, and there is hence also a good chance that you depend on a magical thing called "BART" to get you to work each day.

BART stands for Bay Area Rapid Transit. It's the train system that covers most of San Francisco and the East Bay. It's also a contributing factor to Bay Area residents paying more per mile for public transit than almost anyone else in the world. I pay, quite literally, ten dollars a day for the privilege of leaving my house and going to work. (This assumes I'm not taking any buses, something that isn't always true during the rainy season.) And oh, right, they increased fares and cut back on service earlier this year—something most of us took with grumbling but no real complaint, because the economic realities of California are what they are. The system needs money to keep running. The money has to come from somewhere. Happy? No. Resigned? Yes.

Except now the union is threatening to strike Sunday at midnight. Happy? No. Resigned? No. Royally pissed off?

Oh, yeah.

The union isn't striking for fair working conditions, human rights, or the other things that unions tend to justifiably strike for. The union is, near as I can tell, striking for the right to pretend that we're not in a recession while the system continues to reduce services and hike costs in order to pay for the concessions the union is demanding. I'm a union girl. About two-thirds of my family has or has had union jobs. Unions are amazing things, and without them, the conditions under which the average worker has to labor would be a hell of a lot worse. Even if you're in a non-union job, the odds are good that you've benefited from the unions of the past. If nothing else, unions are at least part of the reason you get things like "breaks" and "bathrooms." All that being said?

Screw you, BART union. I've read all the documentation I could, trying to find a way in which this wasn't an insane thing to do, and I haven't found it. Even my cousin who works for BART has no clue what the hell this is supposed to accomplish, beyond possibly getting a few station agents lynched by their neighbors. Because there is genuinely no way for people who live where I live and don't have access to a car to get to San Francisco without the train. The closest bus route I can put together would take four and a half hours just to get me to the point of being able to transfer to the Transbay Bus to fight the traffic caused by dumping the 350,000 daily BART commuters onto our already over-taxed bridges.

I'm lucky. I probably won't lose my job, even if the BART strike prevents me from getting to work for a few days. But the people who are temping? Working minimum wage janitorial jobs in the city, because they can't afford to live closer, and can't find work anywhere else? Flipping burgers, making smoothies, and doing the things people who can afford to live in San Francisco can also afford not to do? Those people are going to get fired if they can't reach the office because the trains aren't running.

Strikes are good. Strikes are necessary. But maybe striking during a recession when you're already making a living wage and aren't being actively abused in some way is a dick thing to do. And maybe doing it when you know it's going to cripple local transit and lose a lot of people their jobs is a double-dick thing to do. Just in case you were wondering.

Beware. For today I wear the cranky pants.
Tags: cranky blonde is cranky, don't be dumb, travel
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 57 comments
I was born in Concord and my dad used to take BART to his office in San Francisco twenty-some years ago. I'll have to pass this to him, if you don't mind. And ack - I can't believe they think _now_ is a good time to do _this._ ::shakes head::
Pass away!

And yeah. This is just insane, and it's going to undermine future union activities for years.
"When a city has grown so overlarge and crowded that it is in immediate danger of collapse ... when food and clean water flow into the city at a rate just sufficient to feed every mouth, and every hand must work constantly to keep it that way ... when all transportation is involved in moving vital supplies, and none is left over to move people out of the city should the need arise ... then it is that Crazy Eddie leads the movers of garbage out on strike for better working conditions."
--The Mote In God's Eye
Very true.

linenoise

7 years ago

That BS been happening a lot lately. In the past year, Montreal's traffic was crazier than usual because of a similar strike, Ottawa University canceled classes because of the bus strike, NYC's monthly pass went from $75 to $90 to $100 while the metro made cutbacks on workers and service. That area is expensive enough to live in without transportation fees.

I enjoyed my last visit to Alameida, Palo Alto, Berkeley, and oh yeah, San Fran. I'm long overdue for another.
I recommend waiting to make another visit until they've turned the damn trains back on. :(
As a person who (also) lives in Concord, an ex-Bolshie and is wondering how she's going to get to her office by CCSF on Monday morning, I say hell yes to this post.

Reading of the sweet deal that BART employees get, I almost hope that the governor fires all of them on Monday morning - 'cos I know where *I'm* going to apply for a job, then. $82/month for health coverage??? Jaysis!
If you need a ride, lemme know. I have to be in Oakland by ten anyways, so SF isn't much further. Maybe a super-dork carpool with Seanen, yes?

britgeekgrrl

7 years ago

idancewithlife

7 years ago

britgeekgrrl

7 years ago

seanan_mcguire

7 years ago

I remember when this happened in NY, and from what I saw, the extremely wealthy didn't really care much about the striking.

But Lordy, did it affect the the working class, some of whom had to walk home for four or five miles in the dark, because their bosses didn't care that they had no other way of getting in and out and around New York.

It affected the elderly, like my blind fellow synagogue goer who used the train to get her to the doctor (I had worked with her, two stops, down stairs, have train worker direct her east and then next to the Dunkin Doughnuts) or just the bus which took her to the grocery store.

And mothers, who relied on the train to bring their children home from school? They were stranded too.

Honestly, this is what hurts unions. As we discussed when I met you, I'm proudly Jewish and Emma Goldman and Samuel Gompers are part of the heritage. I grew up with the Triangle Shirt factory legacy. Many NYers of various backgrounds had similar heritages, it's a former manufacture city.

But for months, people practically hissed when they saw an MTA worker, people were furious and hissed with rage. It was not pretty.
I genuinely worry about people getting hurt if the strike a) happens and b) endures for any length of time.
During the last threat of strike, when I had the unfortunate situation to need to travel ONE FRIGGING STOP every morning and afternoon, my only plan to link from one bus stop to the other (Pleasant Hill to Walnut Creek, how stupid is that) was to bring along my bicycle and take Iron Horse between the two stops. I would need to get up extra early just to make it happen.

I shudder to think what will happen to people who live in Antioch, and need to travel to Daly City. Might want to look at the Ferries... Where in SF do you work? Downtown? As stupid as it may be, taking the 78 from PH BART (they will stop just outside the station) and take it up to my neck of the woods, and take the Ferry from Vallejo Marina directly to The SF Ferry building.
As a bonus, the Vallejo ferry is a catamaran, fast, and kinda fun.

...but I'm fond of ferries.

-- Lorrie

seanan_mcguire

7 years ago

semy_of_pearls

7 years ago

ZOMG I LIVE IN CONCORD TOO! LET"S HEAR IT FOR C-TOWN!

*dies*

*revives*

And I can offer a ride early Monday if you need one - I have to be in Oakland at ten anyways, SF isn't too much farther than that. And mmm... that's a fab excuse for some Arizmendi's....
Oh, and yes, BART strikes suck. They don't raise awareness like they're supposed to, they just embitter the working populace which supports them in the first place. Not only is BART more expensive than driving 99% of the time, but they're raising prices again and striking. This does not endear me to them.

That said, the booth workers have always been fabulous to me when I get on the wrong line and freak out about getting back (like the d'oy! time I took the Pleasanton line instead of the Pittsburg one), or when I don't know the walking route to my destination from the station.

britgeekgrrl

7 years ago

seanan_mcguire

7 years ago

britgeekgrrl

7 years ago

bigherman

7 years ago

britgeekgrrl

7 years ago

seanan_mcguire

7 years ago

seanan_mcguire

7 years ago

Deleted comment

I live all the way 'cross the country, so I have no vested interest in this particular strike, but considering the disasters CA is going through right now (NPR did a big thing on the jail system in CA yesterday and I'm still fired up) it sounds like some of your unions are in need of a Come To Jesus meeting.

I'd see about getting this entry published in the paper - point some very pointed fingers right at the BART workers striking.
Yeah, California really doesn't need the extra crap right now. I mean, we're already on fire. Literally.
You forgot Alviso which is sitting at the crotgh of the bay.

But, yes, this is why unions are going to hell. I remember (oh, gwads, I'm getting old) when unions protected all working class people, even if they belonged to another union or chose not to.

When I worked at Fairchild and Intel (in the 70's), unions tried to force their way in, but, because those who ran the semi-conductor companies started out by treating their workers fairly, most of the employees laughed at the tactics.

Now the entire world seems to be run on the premise of 'every man for himself, sort of support those who seem to show that they think like me and screw the rest of the world'.
Sadly often true.
I remember when the dockworkers held a strike a few years ago down here. For much the same stupidity.

Imagine container ships as far as you could see out on the ocean. THAT STUPID.

I think I'd be pricelining something in the city for what I would be spending on BART and see if anything took, and enjoy the free housekeeping.

This is so braindead, there aren't words.
...ew.

Just ew.
I used to commute from Berkeley to Oakland and then bus into Alameda five days a week. If I needed to drive to work, I tried to go in as early as possible so that I could get out as early as possible so that I wouldn't have to deal with as much of the crazy-making freeway traffic or the fifteen different construction projects on the streets.

And Berkeley isn't far from Alameda. Not to mention the 2-3 times a week I would BART into SF so I didn't have to drive on the bridge or find parking.

I can totally empathize with the anger of you and britgeekgrrl. Especially since this is over...nothing that the riding public is going to empathize with.

NYAR!
Basically! We're not supporting the strike. Pretty much en masse, we're not supporting the strike. And that's...bad for them.
Hmm. So what looked confusing from where I sit does look rude and thoughtless at close range. I was wondering about that.
Yup!

Deleted comment

It really, really is. My cats may never forgive me.
I don't go into SF very often, but when I do I usually take BART so I can avoid parking. I was in fact just offered a job in SF for late Sept-Oct and the commute w/ BART functioning was giving me pause.

I am hopeful that this strike will still be averted, that the union was just using the biggest stick they had to get negotiations started up again more favorabaly. But reading the coverage I can't support this strike, and I'm a member of a union. They will do nothing but make themeselves horribly unpopular.
Precisely.
This is why people who are otherwise on the same page as me as liberals no longer have much respect for unions. (I'm reminded of this fat too trenchant quote from The Simpsons: You can't treat the working man this way. One day, we'll form a union, and get the fair and equitable treatment we deserve! Then we'll go too far, and get corrupt and shiftless, and the Japanese will eat us alive!"

Having been through both the wrongheadedness of the union leaders and a transit strike, I wish you the best and hope that saner heads prevail.
Thank you.
My local is threatening to do much the same thing. I think they need to lay off the crack. If they go through with it I may tell them to take a flying leap and work anyway.
I wish that didn't sound like the right thing to do. It worries me when I can't have faith in unions.
NALC (David's union) CAN'T strike. Yet they are still a solid bargaining force. I think BART should be in the same boat. My mom sure wished that the CNA wasn't allowed to strike. She always crossed the picket lines when her union went on strike, because, in her opinion, the critical care patients that she was caring for could be hurt or killed if they had to be shuffled around to another hospital. It's not like you can reschedule a heart attack to boycott a hospital.
Your mom is awesome. Because you're right: you can't reschedule a heart attack to boycott a hospital.
Cranky blonde has every right to be cranky. I hope it's a short, short strike.

Tangent: Having just read oneminutemonkey's review of Rosemary and Rue, I wanted to extend an invitation to you to do a guest blog entry over on my blog, Myth, the Universe, and Everything, if you're doing any blog touring for promotion. I've had Carrie Vaughn, Maggie Stiefvater, Tiffany Trent, Shanna Swendson, and a host of others do original guest entries, talking about mythology/folklore and how it relates to their fiction writing. Everyone's got a different take on how to interpret that. :) They usually run about 500 words, and I put them up on Fridays (alternating with excerpts from other sources if I don't have an original entry to put up).

I've also started doing contests on my blog, which I hope will drive up the traffic a bit. The blog syndicates to facebook, my Home Page, amazon, and Tokyopop. Let me know if you'd be at all interested!
I'd be happy to do a guest blog for you! Go ahead and drop me the details through the contact link on my website, if you'd be so kind? I'm a big sucker for anything promo, and anything folklore-related.
. . . . . . .

And another pro-union girl really wants to find some people and kick them in the nads.

NOT ON PEOPLE. NOT ON AT ALL.
YES.
My union, the National Association of Letter Carriers (NALC), is one of the strongest unions in the country, even though we can't legally go on strike. When the time comes to negotiate a new contract, NALC tries to come up with ways to help not only letter carriers, but the postal service as a whole. Our last contract took over a year to hammer out. One of the things we gave ground on was a gradual increasing of our health insurance contributions.

Despite my being a union member, I feel no sense of solidarity with the one BART union that is the focus of this. I think they would get better traction with the public if they showed up to work wearing buttons that read "Working without a contract" in big bold letters.

On the flip side, it is BART management that has determined negotiations are at an impasse. The union reps have said they are still willing to work at the bargaining table, but management has told them to take it or leave it. Management's case is strengthened by the fact that the other two BART employee unions have already ratified their contracts. However, the other two BART unions have stated that they will honor the picket lines.

I'm glad I don't have to deal with a transit strike. You have my sympathies.
Things appear settled for now. Thank you for your sensible commentary.
The Bay Area is actually very large. Yes, there is life outside San Francisco, San Jose, and Oakland. ... Thousands of people live in places with names like "Albany," "Pleasant Hill," "Los Gatos," and "Hercules." I, myself, live in a city called "Concord," which used to be called, at various points in its history, "Canterbury," "Todo Santos," and "The Ass-End of Nowhere."

I was born in San Francisco, lived in Daly City on Westline Drive and grew up in Walnut Creek. But I left there after third grade, so it's probably changed quite a bit since then. :P
P.S. I still remember my address 613 Sitka Drive. Yes, I'm silly.:)

seanan_mcguire

7 years ago