Seanan McGuire (seanan_mcguire) wrote,
Seanan McGuire
seanan_mcguire

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Book review: "The Skewed Throne," Joshua Palmatier.

The Skewed Throne [Amazon]|[Mysterious Galaxies] by Joshua Palmatier.
DAW Books, paperback
384 pages, epic fantasy I bet you don't know where your wallet is
Currently in print

***

The Skewed Throne was handed to me by someone whose opinions on books I was still learning to trust, accompanied by an enthusiastic "try this, you'll like it." Perhaps unsurprisingly, the book (and its two sequels) wound up sitting on my "to be read" shelf for the better part of six months, regularly passed over in favor of volumes that looked like they were more like the sort of thing I tend to read. I'm not a huge fan of epic fantasy, having overdosed on it during my teenage "Dragonlance is high art" years, and will usually opt for horror, urban fantasy, chick-lit, or a fistful of anthologies instead. It took getting annoyed at a horror anthology to make me decide to go ahead and grab the first volume of the trilogy, since hey, they were already in my house.

Sometimes I am very, very glad to push my boundaries, because of the amazing things it allows me to discover. This was one of those times. Because within ten pages, I was neglecting my chores, within fifty pages, I was neglecting my edits, and within a hundred pages, I was going for a long walk to make the cats stop bothering me. Yeah. It's that good.

The Skewed Throne tells the story of Varis, an orphan living in the city of Amenkor, which has basically gone insane after an event called "the White Fire." Streets are falling into disrepair, crime and violence are on the rise, and children like Varis are becoming increasingly common, trying to claw out an existence in the gutters of a part of the city charmingly referred to as "the Dredge." It's really no surprise that she's not a very nice person. It's a bit more of a surprise that she's managed to survive as long as she has, through a combination of luck, skill, and a special gift she calls "the River," which she can use to predict the actions of others.

Amenkor is ruled by the Mistress of the Skewed Throne, a legendary, borderline-religious figure who is in some way responsible for the health and well-being of the entire city. Her powers are sketchily defined, which is part of the book's appeal; we're never given more information than is available to Varis, our point-of-view and central character. Her perspective is so firm, and so skewed from the normal fantasy heroine, that it's easy to accept that this is just the way the world is, the way the world has always been, and the way the world is always going to be. There's just one major problem, a problem severe enough to rip Amenkor apart: the Mistress of the Skewed Throne has been acting erratically since the White Fire, and now signs begin to indicate that she just may be insane...

One of the most interesting aspects of The Skewed Throne is the fact that Varis is, through no real fault of her own, not a very nice person. She kills both in self-defense and semi-professionally. She's not attractive, she's not brilliant, she's not educated, and she's not repentant. Varis doesn't stand around mourning the fact that she's not a good girl. Varis steals your lunch and runs like hell, because she'd really like to eat today, thanks very much. In her world, sitting around feeling sorry for yourself is another way of saying "suicide."

I finished The Skewed Throne and immediately picked up the sequel, The Cracked Throne. I finished The Cracked Throne and bitched and whined at Chris because we were nowhere near the house, and I couldn't start immediately on The Vacant Throne. Three books, all from DAW, all awesome, all available right now. And no, I'm not going very deeply into the story, because it's a lot more interesting if you come into it blind, the way that I did. If you like well-handled epic fantasy with brutally honest, sympathetic-but-not-sweet female protagonists, this is the series for you. Joshua Palmatier does a fantastic job with his world, and I can't wait to see where he's going to go next. (Also, while there is violence, there's no swearing, and no sex. Hand it to a twelve-year-old with a decent vocabulary and watch the summer sweeten.)

I give The Skewed Throne four and a half out of five really creepy-ass iconic chairs, and a strong suggestion that it not walk down any dark alleys alone. I highly recommend it.
Tags: book review
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 9 comments
*added to paperbackswap wish list*

(btw - there is already a wish list on there for _Rosemary and Rue_!)
Do people who use this service tend to buy the books that they read and enjoy?
Think of it as a giant online used bookstore with a really well-maintained waiting list.

Every book you ship to someone else earns you a credit to get something you want. I mostly use it to fill in holes in my collection, get on the list for obscure history books, or first books of series I want to try out. If I like them then I may well buy the next ones.

For example, on your recommendation I wish-listed 'The Stepsister Scheme'. It arrived a few weeks ago, and I adored it. I'm keeping that copy to share with all my friends, and will probably buy the rest when they come out.

It's also a great place to find loving homes for obscure non-fiction that looked great in the catalogue but I don't necessarily need to keep. But there are people out there who WANT my copies of "Thames - a biography" (gods that was DULL) or a series of essays about the relationships between elephants and people.
What worries me slightly about this model is that the second book of a series is often printed according to the first. So if everyone acquires the same ten copies of the first book, thus leading to fifty fans, forty of those fans are invisible...

...and only ten copies of book two will be printed.
True, but that would happen with any used bookstore or library model. (See previous post - broker than broke)

If I check a book out of the library and enjoy it, I might buy more later or I might wait and get them from the library. Does that mean that libraries are bad?

Or I find a nifty book in a used bookstore and keep it and treasure it always. Am I bad because I didn't run over to Borders and spend my grocery money on a new copy? Or is the used bookstore bad for selling the books without giving the author a cut? And what if I loan a copy to a friend?

In a perfect world everyone would be able to buy all the books they wanted in hardcover, but realistically that isn't going to happen. Books get passed around and resold and loved and dropped in the bathtub and nibbled by bunnies and sold by the box at grandma's estate sale.... And the author doesn't get any money after the first sale.
To be clear: I am a huge, huge fan of libraries and used bookstores. I shop at used bookstores more than is technically healthy. The reason this model concerns me at all is because it allows for wish-listing and relatively fast returns, without the feedback of the library computers. There's actually a metric used by libraries to determine how many copies they need, and publishers see that math. Used bookstores and estate sales keep books in circulation, but they do so at a delay; if you want it fast, you go to the new releases shelf.

I do not object to loans, used bookstores, libraries, or putting food on the table. I don't even object to loan models and wish-lists. It just worries me a little, especially when you're talking about new/midlist authors, that there's a fast and organized exchange medium. It's the Tivo viewer's dilemma: I love my Tivo, but right now, my viewings do nothing to improve the ratings of my favorite shows. That's already killed a few awesome series, because the first-run numbers weren't there.

There's no good answer.
*nods*

Now you have me thinking - do things like rental figures get calculated into movie studio's thinking? Or does it just count as a "sale" when Blockbuster or Netflix first buys it? Because I think of PBS as a cross between a library and Netflix.

Guess we just have to live with the model, because PBS has some serious stats:
* Books Available: 3,593,651
* Books Posted in last 60 minutes: 894
* Books Posted All Time: 11,178,596
* Unique Titles Available: 541,076
Books Mailed
* Books Mailed All-Time: 5,428,343
* Books Mailed in last 7 days: 64,807
* Books Mailed Today: 4,291
Members
* Members Online Now: 2,425
* Members Logged In Today: 15,781
* Members in Chat: 6
* Public Profiles: 71,074
Oh, I didn't think I could change the model. I'm not that deluded. Yes, Blockbuster and Netflix rentals count in the thinking of the studios; sadly, fan-run book exchanges don't. See also "why Janet Kagan was never as famous as she should have been."
ok - i was wondering - these are things I know nothing about. Thanks for the info.

I'm hoping the "invisible fan" karma will be somewhat offset by my being able to easily find people who actually WANT that 800pg History of Wales that looked so nifty in the History Book Club catalog for something other than "propping open a window". Or that book about The History of Silicon Valley Venture Capitalists that my brother somehow thought I would like. Or the Spanish language paperbacks I found in the closet when I bought my condo.